Pool Home School
  • Best Guides
    • Heaters
      • Best Pool Heaters
      • Best Solar Pool Heaters
      • Best Electric Pool Heaters
      • Best Gas Pool Heaters
      • Best Propane Patio Heaters
      • Best Whole House Electric Tankless Water Heater Reviews
      • Best Bathroom Heaters
      • Top Hayward Pool Heat Pumps
      • Best Hot Tub Heaters
      • Best Sauna Heaters
    • Pools
      • Above Ground Pool
        • Best Above Ground Pools
        • Best Above Ground Pool Ladders
        • Best Above Ground Pool Lights
        • Best Above Ground Pool Covers
        • Best Above Ground Pool Heaters
        • Best Above Ground Pool Filters
        • Best Above Ground Pool Liner
        • Best Above Ground Pool Pad Reviews
        • Summer Waves vs. Intex
      • Best Kiddie Pools
      • Best Blow Up Pool
      • Coleman vs Intex Pools
    • Pool Cleaners
      • Cleaners by Brand
        • Best Dolphin Pool Cleaners
        • Best Polaris Pool Cleaners
        • Dolphin Quantum Review
      • Comparison
        • Dolphin Premier vs Polaris F9550
        • Dolphin Premier vs Nautilus CC Plus
        • Dolphin Sigma vs Premier
        • Polaris 360 vs Polaris 380
        • Zodiac MX6 vs Zodiac MX8
        • Aquabot vs Dolphin
        • Polaris 280 vs 380
      • Best Automatic Pool Cleaners
      • Best Suction Pool Cleaners
      • Best Above Ground Pool Vacuum for Intex
      • Best Pressure Side Pool Cleaner
      • Best Above Ground Pool Cleaners
      • Best Pool Cleaners for Leaves
    • Swimming supplies
      • Best Swimming Goggles
      • Best Swim Jammers
      • Best Swim Paddles
      • Best Swim Fins
      • Best Earplugs for Swimming
      • Best Nose Clips for Swimming
    • Pool Heat Pumps
    • Best Pool Covers
    • Best Shower Panels
    • Best Floating Pool Lights
    • Best Shower Filters For Hard Water
    • Best Handheld Shower Heads
    • Best Pool Alarm
    • Best Shower Bases & Pans
    • Best Pool Slides
    • Best Pool Floats for Tanning
    • Best Pool Basketball Hoop
    • Best Pool Brushes
    • Best Pool Pumps for Above Ground Pool
    • Best Soaking Tubs
    • Best Vessel Sinks
    • Best Thermostatic Shower Valves
  • best spa guides
    • Best Plug and Play Hot Tubs
    • Best Inflatable Hot Tubs
    • Best Hot Tub Covers
    • Best 2 Person Hot Tubs
    • Best 4 Person Hot Tubs
    • Best Heated Foot Spa
    • Best Portable Infrared Sauna
    • Best Whirlpool Tubs
    • Best Hot Tub Cover Lifters
    • Best 2 Person Saunas
  • Supplies
    • Best Pool Skimmer Basket
    • Best Pool Test Kit
    • Best Pool Chemicals
    • Best Pool Chlorine Tablets
    • Best Salt Water Pool System
    • Best Pool Skimmer
    • Best Telescopic Pool Poles Reviewed
    • Best Paints for Concrete Pool Decks
    • Best Pool Vacuum Heads Reviewed
    • Best Pool Filter Sand
    • Best Pool Lounge Chairs
    • Best Pool Algaecides
    • Best Pool Cover Pumps
    • Best Variable Speed Pool Pumps
    • Best Pool Thermometers
    • Best Pool Test Strips
    • Best Pool Fence
    • Best Baby Floats
    • Best Bathroom Fans
    • Best Corner Shower Caddys
    • Best Pool Umbrellas
    • Best Non Slip Bath Mats
    • Best Shower Drain Hair Catchers
    • Best Tension Shower Rods
  • Blog
    • Health Benefits of a Hot Tub
    • Setting Up a Pool
    • Best Time to Buy a Pool
    • How to Prevent Algae in Pool
    • How to Heat a Pool
    • Types of Diving Boards
    • Best Time to Run a Pool Pump
    • What is a Salt Water Pool
    • How to Level Ground for Pool
    • What to Put Around Above Ground Pool
    • How Much Sand Goes in a Sand Filter for a Pool
    • Pool Filter Types
    • How to Clean Pool Filter
    • How to Clean Pool Liner
    • How to Winterize a Pool
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • Disclosure
    • Privacy Policy
    • About me
Pool Home School
Pool Home School
  • Best Guides
    • Heaters
      • Best Pool Heaters
      • Best Solar Pool Heaters
      • Best Electric Pool Heaters
      • Best Gas Pool Heaters
      • Best Propane Patio Heaters
      • Best Whole House Electric Tankless Water Heater Reviews
      • Best Bathroom Heaters
      • Top Hayward Pool Heat Pumps
      • Best Hot Tub Heaters
      • Best Sauna Heaters
    • Pools
      • Above Ground Pool
        • Best Above Ground Pools
        • Best Above Ground Pool Ladders
        • Best Above Ground Pool Lights
        • Best Above Ground Pool Covers
        • Best Above Ground Pool Heaters
        • Best Above Ground Pool Filters
        • Best Above Ground Pool Liner
        • Best Above Ground Pool Pad Reviews
        • Summer Waves vs. Intex
      • Best Kiddie Pools
      • Best Blow Up Pool
      • Coleman vs Intex Pools
    • Pool Cleaners
      • Cleaners by Brand
        • Best Dolphin Pool Cleaners
        • Best Polaris Pool Cleaners
        • Dolphin Quantum Review
      • Comparison
        • Dolphin Premier vs Polaris F9550
        • Dolphin Premier vs Nautilus CC Plus
        • Dolphin Sigma vs Premier
        • Polaris 360 vs Polaris 380
        • Zodiac MX6 vs Zodiac MX8
        • Aquabot vs Dolphin
        • Polaris 280 vs 380
      • Best Automatic Pool Cleaners
      • Best Suction Pool Cleaners
      • Best Above Ground Pool Vacuum for Intex
      • Best Pressure Side Pool Cleaner
      • Best Above Ground Pool Cleaners
      • Best Pool Cleaners for Leaves
    • Swimming supplies
      • Best Swimming Goggles
      • Best Swim Jammers
      • Best Swim Paddles
      • Best Swim Fins
      • Best Earplugs for Swimming
      • Best Nose Clips for Swimming
    • Pool Heat Pumps
    • Best Pool Covers
    • Best Shower Panels
    • Best Floating Pool Lights
    • Best Shower Filters For Hard Water
    • Best Handheld Shower Heads
    • Best Pool Alarm
    • Best Shower Bases & Pans
    • Best Pool Slides
    • Best Pool Floats for Tanning
    • Best Pool Basketball Hoop
    • Best Pool Brushes
    • Best Pool Pumps for Above Ground Pool
    • Best Soaking Tubs
    • Best Vessel Sinks
    • Best Thermostatic Shower Valves
  • best spa guides
    • Best Plug and Play Hot Tubs
    • Best Inflatable Hot Tubs
    • Best Hot Tub Covers
    • Best 2 Person Hot Tubs
    • Best 4 Person Hot Tubs
    • Best Heated Foot Spa
    • Best Portable Infrared Sauna
    • Best Whirlpool Tubs
    • Best Hot Tub Cover Lifters
    • Best 2 Person Saunas
  • Supplies
    • Best Pool Skimmer Basket
    • Best Pool Test Kit
    • Best Pool Chemicals
    • Best Pool Chlorine Tablets
    • Best Salt Water Pool System
    • Best Pool Skimmer
    • Best Telescopic Pool Poles Reviewed
    • Best Paints for Concrete Pool Decks
    • Best Pool Vacuum Heads Reviewed
    • Best Pool Filter Sand
    • Best Pool Lounge Chairs
    • Best Pool Algaecides
    • Best Pool Cover Pumps
    • Best Variable Speed Pool Pumps
    • Best Pool Thermometers
    • Best Pool Test Strips
    • Best Pool Fence
    • Best Baby Floats
    • Best Bathroom Fans
    • Best Corner Shower Caddys
    • Best Pool Umbrellas
    • Best Non Slip Bath Mats
    • Best Shower Drain Hair Catchers
    • Best Tension Shower Rods
  • Blog
    • Health Benefits of a Hot Tub
    • Setting Up a Pool
    • Best Time to Buy a Pool
    • How to Prevent Algae in Pool
    • How to Heat a Pool
    • Types of Diving Boards
    • Best Time to Run a Pool Pump
    • What is a Salt Water Pool
    • How to Level Ground for Pool
    • What to Put Around Above Ground Pool
    • How Much Sand Goes in a Sand Filter for a Pool
    • Pool Filter Types
    • How to Clean Pool Filter
    • How to Clean Pool Liner
    • How to Winterize a Pool
  • About
    • Contact Us
    • Disclosure
    • Privacy Policy
    • About me

5 Best Hot Tub Heater Reviews & Buying Guide in 2020

Last updated on May 2nd, 2022

  • Steve
5/5 - (3 votes)

You’re looking for the best hot tub heater, are you? Do you know what to look for? We do. We gathered some electricians, installation experts, sales people and hot tub enthusiasts to help us sort through all of the heaters out there. Whittled the stock down to the best, then reviewed all the ones that have outstanding and useful features that you need.

Take a look at the five best ones, then stick around to learn about the features you need and see the answers to the most common questions.

Let’s jump in and find you your new heater. These are the top contenders. Look at each one carefully:

Contents

  • 1 Our Recommended Hot Tub Heaters
  • 2 5 Best Hot Tub Heaters on the Market:
    • 2.1 1. American Standard 9075.120 Safe-T-Heater
    • 2.2 2. Hayward Universal W3H200FDP H-Series Pool And Spa Heater
    • 2.3 3. Hayward CSPAXI11 11-KW Electric Spa Heater
    • 2.4 4. Ecosmart 5.5 Smart Electric Spa Heater
    • 2.5 5. KookYou Pool Heater
  • 3 Factors to Consider When Buying the Best Hot Tub Heater
  • 4 Hot Tub Heater FAQs
  • 5 Summary

Our Recommended Hot Tub Heaters

American Standard 9075.120 Safe-T-Heater
  • View at Amazon!
  • Our Rating:
  • American Standard 9075.120 Safe-T-Heater
  • 1400 watts, 12 amps saves energy

    Installs in Whirlpool hot tubs in two steps

    Limited lifetime warranty.
Jump To Full Review
Hayward W3H200FDP Universal H-Series 200,000 BTU Pool and Spa Heater, Propane
  • View at Amazon!
  • Our Rating:
  • Hayward Universal W3H200FDP H-Series Pool And Spa Heater
  • 200,000 BTU

    Temperature up to 104 degrees F.

    One-year warranty covers parts and labor

Jump To Full Review
Hayward CSPAXI11 11 Kilowatt Electric Spa Heater
  • View at Amazon!
  • Our Rating:
  • Hayward CSPAXI11 11-KW Electric Spa Heater
  • 11 KW at 50 amps makes for fast water heating

    Water temperature adjusts up to 104 degrees F

    One-year parts and labor warranty

Jump To Full Review

5 Best Hot Tub Heaters on the Market:

1. American Standard 9075.120 Safe-T-Heater

  • 1400 watts, 12 amps saves energy
  • Installs in Whirlpool hot tubs in two steps
  • Maintains water temperature regardless out outside temp
  • Easy to operate
  • Limited lifetime warranty
View at Amazon

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

 

American Standard 9075.120 Safe-T-Heater

Review

This is a very user-friendly hot tub heater, at least for Whirlpool tub owners. That’s the only brand it will work with. But it’s pre-plumbed for Whirlpools, so you won’t need a pro for installation.

It keeps the water at a relaxing temperature, but the temp can’t be adjusted. Don’t worry. It’s not too hot or cold. It’s just right, no matter what the weather is like.

What Customers Are Saying

People often remark about how easy it is to use. They also like that they can save a bunch of money by connecting it themselves. Electricity savings is also a hot topic. Some people have remarked that it would be better if the temperature was adjustable, though. At the end of the day, most everyone is satisfied with their purchase.

Pros

  • Uses relatively little electricity
  • Easy to install
  • Easy to operate

Cons

  • Only works with Whirlpool brand hot tubs
  • Temperature isn’t adjustable
Check at Amazon! →

2. Hayward Universal W3H200FDP H-Series Pool And Spa Heater

  • 200,000 BTU burner is cheap to operate compared to bigger propane spa heaters
  • Can be used with any hot tub
  • Professional installation is recommended to keep things simple
  • Adjustable temperature lets you customize the water temp you want, up to 104 degrees F.
  • Low emissions meets all US laws
  • Special heat exchanger construction will last for years, even with acidic water
  • One-year warranty covers parts and labor
View at Amazon

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

 

Hayward W3H200FDP Universal H-Series 200,000 BTU Pool and Spa Heater, Propane

Review

This propane hot tub heater lets you adjust the temperature of your water to your liking, as long as that’s not over 104 degrees F. And it doesn’t take a lot of propane to do it. It’s on the smaller side, so it takes longer to heat the water up, but that saves gas.

It will fit any tub, but installation is rather difficult. Pro installation would be a wise choice if you’ve never done anything like this before.

What Customers Are Saying

They really like that the temperature is adjustable. The energy savings compared to more powerful heaters comes up a lot, too. The biggest complaint is about Hayward’s response to warranty claims.

They don’t have the best customer service, and their authorized warranty repair shops are few and far between. People love this heater unless they encounter a malfunction that necessitates a warranty claim.

Pros

  • Adjustable temperature
  • Energy efficient
  • Low emissions
  • Long-lasting

Cons

  • Bad customer service
  • Rather expensive
Check at Amazon! →

3. Hayward CSPAXI11 11-KW Electric Spa Heater

  • 11 KW at 50 amps makes for fast water heating
  • Water temperature adjusts up to 104 degrees F for the perfect soak
  • Clear and detailed instructions are included for easy installation
  • Easy to set and operate
  • Small size fits into small spaces for concealment
  • One-year parts and labor warranty
View at Amazon

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Hayward CSPAXI11 11 Kilowatt Electric Spa Heater

Review

If you’re looking for a powerful electric spa heater, this may be the one for you. It heats water up fast. It is rather costly to operate if it’s used often.

You shouldn’t have any problems because it is built well. But the warranty is short and many have gotten the run-around from Hayward when they had a problem and needed to get some warranty work done.

What Customers Are Saying

According to people who use this heater, its best feature is the speed at which it heats the water. But that uses a lot of electricity. That’s something that folks complain about. And then there’s Hayward’s customer service, which receives a lot of complaints. Just like the Hayward’s propane heater, people love it unless they have to file a warranty claim.

Pros

  • Heats water quickly
  • Small and easy to hide
  • Easy to install
  • Easy to operate

Cons

  • Uses a lot of electricity
  • Bad customer service
Check at Amazon! →

4. Ecosmart 5.5 Smart Electric Spa Heater

  • Tankless design is efficient and compact
  • 5.5 KW, 30 amps adds to the efficiency
  • Installation is simple and instructions are included
  • Water temp is adjustable from 80 to 104 degrees F.
  • Two-year warranty
View at Amazon

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Ecosmart 5.5 Smart Electric Spa Heater

Review

This is a tankless hot tub water heater. That means that it heats water as it is pumped through. It’s very efficient, since it is only on when the water drops below your setting. And it is very small, only about 12”x10-½” and 5” deep. It can be concealed pretty easily so it doesn’t become an eyesore.

What Customers Are Saying

Many are amazed at the heating capability that such a small unit has. Some people have hung theirs on the wall behind their hot tubs. There are a lot of online reviews that mention the power savings as well. This is one of the best-reviewed spa heaters on the market right now.

Pros

  • Very efficient
  • Compact
  • Adjustable temperature

Cons

  • Can be expensive to have serviced outside of the warranty period
Check at Amazon! →

5. KookYou Pool Heater

  • 15 KW at 50 amps provides the quickest heating
  • Universal - Can be used with any hot tub
  • Adjustable from 86 to 149 degrees F for the hottest soak in your tub
  • Customer installation is possible with experience, but professional installation is recommended
  • Easy to set and use
  • One-year warranty on parts and labor
View at Amazon

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

 

KOOKYOU Pool Heater Thermostat 15KW 220V Water Heater Thermostat for Swimming Pool SPA Hot Tub Electric Water Heater Pump Assistant Digital Thermostat

Review

Are you looking for a jacuzzi heater that will get your water really hot really fast? If so, take a good look at this one. The raw power of this unit is its greatest feature.

It is hard to install, but simple to operate. Unfortunately, there isn’t much to go on in the way of customer service. This is a relatively new company, so there’s little info about them. But the price is right, so it may be worth taking the chance if you want the most powerful heater you can get.

What Customers Are Saying

Be warned: According to people who’ve actually done it themselves, this heater is pretty hard to install. The big problem is the instructions. If you don’t have any experience in both electrical work and plumbing, you may have a heck of a time. But it is easy to set. And the water gets really hot, according to customers.

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Much higher max temp than most other heaters
  • Heats quickly

Cons

  • Very hard-to-understand installation instructions
  • Water at the maximum temperature may actually cause burns
Check at Amazon! →

Factors to Consider When Buying the Best Hot Tub Heater

Know Your Hot Tub Heaters

You must know what you’re looking for in order to get what you need. Study the things to look for and the frequently asked question to understand the matter deeply.

Things To Look For In A Hot Tub Heater

So, what features are important? Pay attention here, especially if this will be your first spa heater. Don’t worry, there’s really only a few main things you need to consider.

Power Source

Ecosmart 5.5 Smart Electric Spa HeaterDo you need an electric, propane or natural gas model? Gas is the most efficient and cheapest to operate, with power rating being the same.

So you should probably go with gas if you can. But electric units are pretty efficient nowadays, so don’t be afraid of them.

Gas and electric heaters heat the water at basically the same amount of time. Cost of operation is the key here. Gas is cheaper in all localities within the continental United States. Check your rates if you live in another country.

Electric Power Rating

The lowest you should go is 5.5 kilowatts. Anything less than that will have a hard time keeping the water hot.

And that’s usually all heaters of this power rating can do. They don’t raise the temperature much, but they do keep the temp steady.

If you want to actually raise the temperature and keep it up, you likely need a heater with a rating of at least 10 kilowatts. They use more electricity, but they heat water fast and keep it hot.

Generally speaking, the higher the kilowatt rating, the quicker the heater will get the water up to your desired temp.

Gas Power Rating

Hayward W3H200FDP Universal H-Series 200,000 BTU Pool and Spa Heater, PropaneThis is measured in BTUs. A 200,000 BTU heater is as small as you’ll want to go, even if your tub is small.

For a four-person tub, you’ll need about 400,000 BTUs. If you want the fastest heat, go with 500,000. Anything above that is a waste, because water can only be heated so quickly.

Ease Of Installation

You can save a lot of money by installing your heater yourself. But some are really hard to install.

Check and see how easy it is for DIY’ers. You may need to pay a pro to install it for you, and you don’t want that to be an unexpected expense.

Warranty

Don’t settle for less than a one-year warranty. Rarely, a heater may have a factory defect. It may take a while for it to become apparent. So you need to have a year to run the heater through its paces to make sure it isn’t defective.

Since repairing these kinds of heaters can be costly, a three-year or lifetime warranty is often worth the extra cost that they add to the price.

Hot Tub Heater FAQs

What Is A Tankless Hot Tub Heater?

They don’t work by keeping a big tank of water hot. They work by heating water as it is pumped through them by the spa’s circulation pump. That makes them very efficient. Most of them are pretty easy to install as well.

Are All Heater Adjustable?

Some people have made the mistake of buying a heater without looking to see if it is capable of heating water. That may sound silly, but some less powerful models only take the chill out of water and maintain its temperature. If you don’t want really hot water, that’s fine. But if you like a hot soak, make sure you get a heater that actually raises the temperature of the water.

How Hot Do Heaters Make The Water?

Most have a maximum temp of 104 degrees F. That’s enough for the vast majority of folks. If you do some searching, you can find heaters that get hotter. The KookYou Spa heater that we reviewed above, for example, get up to almost 150 degrees F. Be careful. That’s too hot. You don’t want to get burned.

Summary

The top electric heater is the Ecosmart Smart Electric Spa Heater. It is the cheapest to operate, and it gets the water up to the standard and safe 104 degrees F. It’s also very compact and easy to hide. If you want really hot water, consider the KookYou heater. It heats the water up to almost 150 degrees F, and it does it quickly.

As far as gas models go, our favorite is the 200,000 BTU Hayward Universal W3H200FDP H-Series Pool And Spa Heater. It does the job efficiently and won’t cost you an arm and a leg.

Go ahead and get the best hot tub heater for your spa today. The sooner you get it installed, the sooner you can spend some nice relaxing time in your jacuzzi.

Pool Home School
Copyright © 2020 PoolHomeSchool. All RIGHTS RESERVED.PoolHomeSchool is a participant of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program – it is designed to provide an aid for the websites in earning an advertisement fee – by means of advertising and linking to Amazon.com products.